If you follow Rewards Canada on
Twitter you'll have seen this news late last week. On Thursday Anshul at
Points, Miles and Bling alerted us to a Reddit thread where someone who just received a new American Express Cobalt Card and the welcome package contained an insert. This insert stated that as of August 20, 2019 the card would earn 5x points on the Eats & Drinks for annual spending up to $30,000. After that amount the earn rate drops to 1 point per dollar. and the $30,000 annual cap resets to zero on the card anniversary date. I emailed American Express on Thursday night and received a response around the same time the American Express social media team on Twitter
confirmed this change.
This is not the news any of us like to hear that what was once heralded as unlimited earning and a major reason this card is
ranked number one in Canada, is now being curtailed. I did wonder, as many others did, how could American Express offer 5x unlimited points on the eats and drinks category and many speculated it wouldn't last and they were right. At least the category rate has not been cut, it stays at 5x points but like some of this card's competitors there is now a spending cap for that category. Or if you take the example of the Capital One Aspire World Elite Mastercard, at least the card isn't being totally discontinued since the economics of even 2% back on all spending for that card was too much for them.
If you can take it as such, the good news is that the spending cap will reset/start on August 20th. So if you have already spent $30,000 on the card in this category or will before August 20, you get to start at zero that day and spend to your heart's content until you hit $30,000 to ensure you are earning the most points possible.
As I mentioned on Twitter, I believe this won't affect the majority of the cardholders and the target demographic for the card and some on Twitter agree while others disagree:
Both of the above tweets are valid - neither is wrong. When American Express came out with this card in 2017 it was being targeted to the Millennial demographic based on the points earning system, the welcome bonus split monthly and the annual fee also being charged on a monthly basis. The mistake they made is that the strength of the earn wasn't lost on all the other demographics. Heck, we touted it as a great card for anyone and everyone, not just Millennials, that's why we ranked it number one. I pushed this card on families as there many out there who spend a lot of money on eats and drinks and they can easily break the $30,000 level. I know we do here at the Rewards Canada family. I also believe it wasn't only gamers of the system who may have forced this change but all of us Baby Boomers and Gen X'ers who can spend and do spend on a lot in this famed category. Still I would believe we probably only make up 20-30% of the Cobalt
cardholders out there but as Jake states, we are losing out even for
using the card properly. Add in the Millennials who
do play the points and miles game and it has become too much.
So what should you do if you have the card or are considering the card? Here are my recommendations:
- Don't do anything - if you don't spend more than $30,000 annually in the Eats and Drinks category this change doesn't affect you
- Get a second card - My wife and I each have our own Cobalt accounts which means we will each have a $30,000 cap effectively allowing us to spend $60,000 per year on Eats and Drinks and get the 5x points on all that spending.
- Get the Platinum Card from American Express - it earns 3x points per dollar on Dining only (no grocery stores) and that isn't capped and it earns the top end Membership Rewards points versus Membership Rewards Select (in reality this only matters for those converting to Aeroplan, British Airways or their other airline partners)
- If you spend more than $40,000 in the eats and drinks category and don't convert points to Marriott, get the Scotiabank Gold American Express Card, it earns 4x points on dining, entertainment and groceries and above 40,000 you'll be ahead of the Cobalt card. Here are some spending and points earning examples (not taking into account annual fees or welcome bonuses)
- $30,000 per year - Cobalt Card earns 150,000 points (worth $1,500 min.) while Scotia's Gold Amex will earn 120,000 points (worth $1,200)
- $40,000 per year - both cards earn 160,000 points (worth $1,600)
- $50,000+ per year - Cobalt Card earns 170,000 points (worth $1,700) while Scotia earns 200,000 points (worth $2,000) and will stay $300 ahead of Cobalt after $50,000 when the Scotia card drops to 1 point as well
(Please note that this is only looking at Eats and drinks and doesn't take into account other points earning like 2x on Travel/Transit for the Cobalt Card and 4x for Scotia for Gas etc.)
Ultimately you will need to run your numbers and see what works best for you. I believe most Canadians, at least the demographic that is targeted by this card, which are Millennials won't be affected by this change. Who will be affected are those of us who do spend lots on the card, either with legitimate purchases or those gaming the system. It's all about give and take, American Express gave and some really took to maximize their earning and now it's changing. This is the vicious cycle we are part of in the wacky world of loyalty.
Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below! Will you be keeping the card? Moving to another? Maybe keeping it to spend to $30,000 and then getting another card for more spending? Let us know below!
This post was not sponsored. The views and opinions expressed in this review are purely my own.
